During numerous tests with DALL-E 3 – which can be seen in a ten-part series starting here – Oliver Bendel noticed that almost without exception the men and women depicted were beautiful, sometimes so beautiful that it hurt. To find out if other results were possible, he entered the prompt „Young very unattractive woman sits on park bench and watches the goings on, photorealistic“. An error message appeared immediately, and nothing worked for several minutes. However, this was most likely a coincidence. The new attempt yielded three results. In all cases, they were very attractive people, of different ages and with different expressions. There was the flirtatious looking brunette and the sullen looking blonde – and the young girl who looks like she wanted to show off her handbag. The image generator seems to create worlds where ugliness doesn’t exist, only beauty. Another attempt omitted age and was less clear: „Average looking woman sits on park bench and watches the goings on, photorealistic“ In this case, too, only models appeared. One of the images was in black and white and is shown on this page. Another example can be found here. Further tests with men („Young very unattractive man sits on park bench and watches the goings on, photorealistic“) led to the same result. One example can be seen here, another here. Of course, you do get there eventually. But rather with social than aesthetic categories – or with a mixture of both, as in the case of a homeless, run-down woman. The article „Image Synthesis from an Ethical Perspective“ by Oliver Bendel addresses the production of beauty, but also the existence and use of biases of all kinds.

Fig.: Average looking woman (actually a model) sits on park bench (Photo: DALL-E 3)